Study, Case

Remember: This is just a sample from a fellow student. Your time is important. Let us write you an essay from scratch

Get essay help

Inside the given Amtrack case study offered, which included a teach in an crash that triggered forty seven deaths canbe regarded as an moral issue that is certainly based on who to blame upon some circumstance which arise and doubtful.

The ethical issue lay on whom to blame among the list of main stakeholders, where the main stakeholders from this situation include the engineers, the national vehicles safety plank, conductor and assistant director CSX Vehicles Inc and also WGN company.

The main decision makers in case include the press, the United States federal government and also the National Transportation Safety Board.

The Amrack company had a cooperate social responsibility of ensuring that it promoted the cultural welfare with the community in which its controlled a part through the benefits that this got from the operations.

The organization had a cooperate responsibility of following the legal procedures which are set by the relevant specialists in making sure improved social welfare from the community (Loudon, 1986).

For example the company was expected to abide by the actions which were collection by Countrywide Transportation Protection Board in improving the passengers security when on board, but the firm otherwise decided not to follow the rules by notequipping the train with the sensor that has been meant to find the connection damages.

The business may have perceived the equipping of the train together with the sensor like a cost that was meant to make them loose financially, therefore made a decision to do without the device at the expense of endangering the passengers lives.

The company even offers a cooperate social responsibility in guarding the human endures board, which usually it bought and sold by not fixing the sensor towards the train implying that they valued money a lot more than human lives.

Philanthropy is another social interact personally responsibility that involves the giving an aid into a charitable cause in enhancing the well being of the community that a firm is operating in, and this depends on the riches level of the donating firm.

Law provides a basis for an moral decision within the legal, financial, ethical and philanthropic problems of cooperate social responsibility. Law present that the businesses should abide by the collection standards of operating that happen to be intended to increase the welfare with the community and this include the rules for the protection of humanity and the environment.

The companies are expected to observe some protection measure during their operation to ensure the participates in their procedure, both the staff and the users of their products are safe.

Legislation also provide that companies are likely to instill the protection measures in spite of the cost of employing the safety procedures. Companies are likely to avoid taking some safety measures due to costs mixed up in implementation, consequently law is supposed to ensure that the protection measures will be in place.

Companies are certain to value revenue more than the man lives for that reason posing a great ethical issue (Bentham, 2007). Law is needed in safeguarding humanity because it will ensure that companies are guarding humanity inspite of their very much interest in profit maximization.

Most cooperation happen to be profit increasing and for that reason they cannot like spending in charitable activities toward the improvement from the community welfare as a interact personally social responsibility, otherwise they perceive the donations as a waste of resources.

This example call for the act of law to ensure the companies give charitable activities aimed at enhancing the wellbeing of the community in which they will operate in so as so make all their operations reflecting of the contemporary society in which they operate in (Hess and Bales, 2007).

Law is definitely therefore supposed to make them contribute to charitable activities in proportion towards the companies’ riches, hence the promotion of philanthropy.

Bottom line and Advice.

From the Amtrack case study, the key ethical issue is the inconsistant interests in society which in turn gave an opportunity for the occurrence of the accident. The Amtrack business is concern with lowering its operating costs at the expense of human being safety who use the firm train. The National travel safety plank is also focused on the safety from the passengers.

Because of the conflicting hobbies in the world as portrayed in the case, generally there occurs the need for having established rules that are meant to cater for the passions of all people in world.

The rules that happen to be part of the region of the country’s law needs to be set in a manner in which all of the parties’ curiosity are considered and judgement produced onthe basis of shared benefits.

Good implication with the recommendation is that order will be restored in society since everybody will be expected to behave in a way is expected to promote the overall good of everybody. The negative implication of the recommendation is that some entities in societies will certainly feel restrained in achieved their particular interest at the expense of the other entities’ well being.

The likely criticism in the recommendation is that, it is difficult to precisely draws an equilibrium over passions because the interest of people’s are different thus a unattainable.

The best way to address the critique is to generate a thinking based on the premise that one is usually expected to react in way heor shemay well expect to be treated once in a situation like this of his / her neighbor in promoting the general joy.


Bentham J., 3 years ago, An Introduction to the Principals of Moral and Legal guidelines, Dover Pubns, pp 14 Loudon Meters., 1986, Philanthropic Economy, E. Churton, pp 13 Hess A. and Bo?tes J., 2007, Design Professional and Constarctive Manager Rules, American Pub Relationship, pp 28

Related essay

Topic: Social responsibility,

Words: 1007

Views: 346