Dunkirk and the Battle of Britain Essay
Sources A, B and C all give info on what happened in the battle of Dunkirk and about the evacuation. All three sources were authored by British persons which means that the sources could be biased or contain wrong information. Resource A was written by Commander Thomas Kerr, a naval officer delivered to organise the evacuation.
Because the naval officer is British we can speculate that the resource is prejudiced. Thomas Kerr starts off by saying What a terrible night that was, for there were got hold of chances and ends of an military services, not the fighting troops. – this kind of suggests to us it turned out a horrible evening, the soldiers they had got were like the leftovers from the battle, they were depressed, starving and they had low morale we know that this may be true because in the DVD AND BLU-RAY we found in class known as The Very best Hour’, a documentary about the expulsion of Dunkirk from a BBC television series, we see soldiers like Peter Vaux who have hadn’t eaten for a few days and was incredibly tired.
This kind of source tells us that they weren’t fighting troops which we are able to say is valid because if all the suggestions above happen to be true, we are able to truly determine that the troops weren’t ready to fight. Jones Kerr procedes say There were hardly any officers, plus the few present were useless- this implies that there were hardly any officers remaining because they will could have been killed or captured during the evacuation, and for those that were their very own they were probably so taken aback by the events going on that they can could no more instruct. It may also show that the officers there were tired or wounded, so they couldn’t perform much.
This could be biased since Thomas Kerr could be looking to make all of us think that the officers had been useless in an attempt to make him or different naval commanders look good. Thomas Kerr then simply says but our assure of protection, and the view of our naviero uniforms, resorted some so that it will the rabble- this tells us that the navy blue was appealing the soldiers safety and that their glorious’ uniforms resorted some order to the rabble, this can be seen as biased because Thomas Kerr is producing us feel that the navy blue was highly effective and expressing it like though the navy blue were the leaders, he himself is known as a part of the navy blue and just would like to make them appearance superior and heroic.
Jones Kerr finally says Their faith inside the navy was pathetic; we’re able to only perform our greatest. – this kind of suggests that the soldiers didn’t really have confidence in the navy blue that they considered them because they did everybody else, it then shows that they can only do their best. Overall, this supply gives all of us a lot of information in what happened in the evacuation of Dunkirk even though quite a bit of the knowledge is prejudiced, in favour of the British as well as the navy there is some truth in the origin.