Film gothika essay

In the 2003 film “Gothika” Halle Super berry plays a psychiatrist who loses her memory and wakes up in an insane asylum, the same one where your woman had previously been an employee physician. She is confused, discombobulated and has lost period. Pete, a psychiatrist played out by Robert Downey Junior., is the doctor assigned to her care and Doug, her husband, have been the doctor in charge of the facility. Miranda, Berry’s character, sooner or later learns that her spouse has been slain and that she has been arrested and recharged with his killing (Kassovitz, 2003).

Remember: This is just a sample from a fellow student. Your time is important. Let us write you an essay from scratch

In the very beginning, the movie pretends to psychology proper. But however, it is typically just failing. The first problem in the motion picture occurs while using description of Miranda’s psychotic break and the actions bringing about it. The doctors caring for Miranda argue that her mental illness resulted from her accident, not the other way around. At first, they simply describe her health issues as a traumatic amnesia brought on by the fear of murdering her partner.

Or, they claim, the sleepwalking might be associated with the head personal injury from the vehicle accident and not related to her mental condition.

Her doctor as well asks her about drugs that your woman may took to cause the violence (killing her husband) or her sleepwalking. While it is suitable to be concerned with a drug-related cause for daydreaming (Merck, 2007) it is silly to believe that those involved in her treatment will not have carried out blood checks to find drug use prior to the asking yourself. The movie tells us Miranda has become out of touch with her mind for three times when the girl awakens in the asylum, therefore the mere idea that they would not need conducted bloodstream tests and have the results backside by then appears implausible.

Another major blunder the movie makes in its portrayal of Miranda’s mental illness and treatment is that Pete is given to do her evaluation. Although it can be asserted that in some areas he might be the only doctor available, as one can be dead and another accused of the killing, the story emerged before the fact of treatment standards in the movie. It seems as though Berry’s character might even recognize this as the lady tries to get a handle on her romantic relationship with Pete, asking him if they had a great affair or wanted to have one main (Kassovitz, 2003).

This right away calls into question the ethics with the doctor plus the accuracy of any view he makes regarding her condition. The film in that case tries to confuse the viewer with the question of whether Miranda is suffering some sort of psychotic break ro is really being haunted by spirits. From a diagnostic point of view, Miranda’s symptoms include the fugue when she was admitted, her lack of memory, and ultimately, though she’s loathe to admit this to her doctor, seeing and hearing her “ghost”. (Kassovitz, 2003).

The film actually goes in terms of to have Miranda address her hallucination, stating “: We am a rational person. I believe in science. We don’t have confidence in the dukun, and I avoid believe in ghosts. But if you are the ghost of Rachel Parsons, are you able to let me out of this cell? ” (Kassovitz, 2003). The professionals, upon experiencing her adventure of finding ghosts, approach right from a diagnosis of distressing amnesia into a diagnosis of schizophrenia, skipping proper part delusional. This is not exact in the least. Initially, there is Miranda’s statement regarding her interaction with the ghosting.

She is still logical enough to know that interaction using a ghost is usually unreasonable and generally accepted being a mental problems. “Schizophrenia is definitely characterized by psychosis (loss of contact with reality), hallucinations (false perceptions), delusions (false beliefs), disorganized presentation and behavior, flattened have an effect on (restricted range of emotions), cognitive deficits (impaired reasoning and problem solving), and occupational and cultural dysfunction. ” (Merck, 2007) If your woman were schizophrenic, it is improbable that she’d have maintained her reasonable mind enough to realize that she was being illogical.

The simple fact that her educated brain could still identify her behaviors while irrational is one of the clearest signals that the lady was not affected by the intellectual deficits linked to schizophrenia. Subsequent, there is the physical appearance of the ghosting herself. In the event Miranda’s delusions had been limited to fleeting photos or auditory hallucinations, her symptoms would have been in line with schizophrenia. Nevertheless , the presence of an identifiable visible hallucination makes the illness even more in line with the symptoms of delusional disorders than schizophrenia (Allpsych, 2007).

“A delusion is known as a belief that is certainly clearly phony and that indicates an problem in the affected person’s content of thought. The fake belief can be not accounted for by the person’s cultural or perhaps religious backdrop or his or her level of cleverness. The key characteristic of a delusion is the degree to which the person is persuaded that the idea is true. A person having a delusion will hold firmly for the belief irrespective of evidence for the contrary. Delusions can be difficult to distinguish coming from overvalued suggestions, which are unreasonable ideas that the person keeps, but the affected person has in least several level of doubt as to it is truthfulness.

A person which has a delusion is completely convinced that the delusion is definitely real. ” (Mind Disorders, 2007). In reality that in the event Miranda had been suffering from possibly of these mental disorders, her symptoms could have 1) recently been more severe in the case of schizophrenia or 2) come with a total belief in her misconception. She would will no longer question if ghosts were real. The ultimate implied diagnosis of the film is that Miranda has been battling abuse as a result of a sadistic and sneaky serial monster who as well happens to be her husband.

Once the ghost potential clients Miranda with her husband’s self applied and abuse chamber, the viewer is left with the impression that Miranda’s mental illness such as delusion of seeing the ghost was her mind’s way of coping with the risk from her husband and becoming strong enough to handle his abuse. This is total and say Hollywood tripe. While it may be possible for battered woman to reduce control and kill her husband in a situation where the lady fears on her behalf life, Miranda’s symptoms are completely out of synchronize with the standard description of BWS (McElroy, 2002).

Probably, this was an effort by the copy writer to draw sympathy intended for the character that did, in fact , kill her husband. In the event the movie had intended to represent mental health issues in an suitable fashion, it simply would have to quit with the apparent ghost account. The problem is that the copy writer wanted to build a story where a ghost was used to explain apart mental disease or a mental illness was sued to explain away a great encounter with the supernatural. No matter what, they failed. By demonstrating the viewers the ghost, the audience does not problem Miranda’s sanity.

After all, we have seen that too. To become more in touch with the analysis they were almost certainly going for, schizophrenia, the movie should have relied by using an unseen presence and given perfectly fair explanations for things that happen, i. e. show Pete going out of her cellular unlocked so that she an escape and conduct her investigation. As it is, the film fails as a ghost story and fails being a psychological thriller. Had it been performed properly, it could have succeeded at equally.


“Delusions” , The fall of 18, 3 years ago. Kassovitz, Mathieu (Director) and Sebastian Guitierrez (Writer). “Gothika”. USA: Columbia Pictures, 2003. McElroy, Wendy. “Battered Women’s Syndrome: Science or Sham? ” The Independent Company, October 28, 2002< http://www. independent. org/aboutus/person_detail. asp? id=488>The fall of 18, 2007. “Prognosis and Treatment”, November 19, 2007. Psychotic Disorders, < http://allpsych. com/disorders/psychotic/index. html>, Nov 18, 2007.

one particular

Related essay